- Original article
- Open Access
The Candidate Genes Underlying a Stably Expressed QTL for Low Temperature Germinability in Rice (Oryza sativa L.)
Rice volume 13, Article number: 74 (2020)
Direct seeding is an efficient cultivation technique in rice. However, poor low temperature germinability (LTG) of modern rice cultivars limits its application. Identifying the genes associated with LTG and performing molecular breeding is the fundamental way to address this issue. However, few LTG QTLs have been fine mapped and cloned so far.
In the present study, the LTG evaluation of 375 rice accessions selected from the Rice Diversity Panel 2 showed that there were large LTG variations within the population, and the LTG of Indica group was significantly higher than that of Japonica and Aus groups (p < 0.01). In total, eleven QTLs for LTG were identified through genome-wide association study (GWAS). Among them, qLTG_sRDP2–3/qLTG_JAP-3, qLTG_AUS-3 and qLTG_sRDP2–12 are first reported in the present study. The QTL on chromosome 10, qLTG_sRDP2–10a had the largest contribution to LTG variations in 375 rice accessions, and was further validated using single segment substitution line (SSSL). The presence of qLTG_sRDP2–10a could result in 59.8% increase in LTG under 15 °C low temperature. The expression analysis of the genes within qLTG_sRDP2–10a region indicated that LOC_Os10g22520 and LOC_Os10g22484 exhibited differential expression between the high and low LTG lines. Further sequence comparisons revealed that there were insertion and deletion sequence differences in the promoter and intron region of LOC_Os10g22520, and an about 6 kb variation at the 3′ end of LOC_Os10g22484 between the high and low LTG lines, suggesting that the sequence variations of the two genes could be the cause for their differential expression in high and low LTG lines.
Among the 11 QTLs identified in this study, qLTG_sRDP2–10a could also be detected in other three studies using different germplasm under different cold environments. Its large effect and stable expression make qLTG_sRDP2–10a particularly valuable in rice breeding. The two genes, LOC_Os10g22484 and LOC_Os10g22520, were considered as the candidate genes underlying qLTG_sRDP2–10a. Our results suggest that integrating GWAS and SSSL can facilitate identification of QTL for complex traits in rice. The identification of qLTG_sRDP2–10a and its candidate genes provide a promising source for gene cloning of LTG and molecular breeding for LTG in rice.
Rice is the staple food for over half of the world population. Therefore, rice production plays a critical role in world food security. However, rice production is facing the threats of labor shortage, energy scarcity, decline of water table, and change in climatic conditions, which drive rice cultivation techniques to shift from traditional puddle transplanting to direct seeding (Singh et al. 2013). Being a simple, labor-saving and efficient cultivation technique, direct seeding has been adopted in many countries and will become an inevitable trend in rice-growing areas. No matter what environment, rapid and uniform germination during initial phase of seedling establishment is one of the essential phenotypic traits defined as early seedling vigour in rice direct seeding (Mahender et al. 2015). Due to tropical or subtropical origin, the optimum temperature for germination of cultivated rice is 25–35 °C, but the temperatures during sowing period are frequently below 15 °C in temperate and high elevation tropical and sub-tropical regions (Fujino et al. 2004). Poor germination and weak seedling establishment caused by low temperature, and subsequently decrease in yields has become one of the major factors limiting the application of direct seeding in rice.
Development and use of rice variety with high low temperature germinability (LTG) is the most economical way to solve this problem. However, the previous studies suggest that rice LTG is a quantitative trait controlled by multiple genes (Han et al. 2006; Jiang et al. 2006; Borjas et al. 2016; Satoh et al. 2016; Jiang et al. 2017). Therefore, it is difficult to develop rice variety with high LTG using the conventional breeding methods. Understanding the genetic basis of LTG is the key for high LTG rice breeding. The development and application of molecular marker technology and high through-put genotyping techniques provide powerful tools for genetic analysis of LTG in rice. So far, a large number of QTLs for LTG in rice have been identified using bi-parental QTL analysis (Miura et al. 2001; Fujino et al. 2004; Han et al. 2006; Jiang et al. 2006, 2017; Wang et al. 2011; Li et al. 2013; Ranawake et al. 2014; Borjas et al. 2016; Satoh et al. 2016). With the rapid development of genome sequencing technology, genome-wide association study (GWAS) based on linkage disequilibrium (LD) has emerged as a powerful tool for identifying the genes underlying complex traits in rice (Huang et al. 2010; McCouch et al. 2016). Compared with the bi-parental QTL analysis, GWAS is more efficient in identification of genes underlying complex traits due to use of a diverse natural population with more recombinant events and highly dense markers such as single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs). When population structure is reasonable and the molecular marker density is large enough, most of the loci associated with traits can be theoretically identified, and the accuracy of marker location can reach the level of gene (Yu and Buckler 2006). In the past few years, GWAS has been also used for identification of LTG QTLs in rice (Fujino et al. 2015; Sales et al. 2017; Schläppi et al. 2017; Shakiba et al. 2017; Wang et al. 2018a, b), and some loci overlap with the previous LTG QTLs identified by bi-parental QTL analysis.
Progress has been made in fine mapping and cloning of LTG QTLs in rice. The qLTG3–1 has been successfully cloned using map-based cloning approach (Fujino et al. 2008). The qLTG3–1 is strongly expressed in the embryo during seed germination and tightly associated with vacuolation, and the elevated vacuolation observed in the NIL suggests that the function of qLTG3–1 may be to accelerate vacuolation and to be involved in the weakening of tissues covering the embryo during the seed germination process (Fujino et al. 2008). The major-effect LTG QTL, qLTG-9 has been fine mapped to a 72.3 kb region on chromosome 9 by using near-isogenic lines and five candidate genes were identified (Li et al. 2013). In addition, Wang et al. (2018a) performed a GWAS of LTG using 187 rice accessions under 12 °C low temperature and confirmed that OsSAP16 (Stress-Associated Protein 16, LOC_Os07g38240) coding a zinc-finger domain protein was the causal gene of QTL qLVG7–2. Loss of OsSAP16 function reduces germination while greater expression of OsSAP16 enhances germination at low temperature. The rice accessions with extremely high and low LTG exhibited correspondingly high and low OsSAP16 expression levels under low temperatures, suggesting that the variation in expression of the OsSAP16 contributes to LTG variation in the natural accessions tested.
Although numerous LTG QTLs in rice have been identified and mapped, these QTLs have not been effectively used in rice breeding. The uncertainty of these QTLs could be one of the main reasons related to this issue. The identified QTLs should be validated, fine mapped or even cloned before marker-assisted selection can be effectively deployed. However, most of the identified LTG QTLs in rice have not been validated and few of them have been fine mapped and cloned. On the other hand, rice LTG is a quantitative trait controlled by multiple genes and the expression of QTL for LTG is frequently affected by environments and genetic backgrounds. Thus, identifying the LTG QTL with large effect and stable expression in different cold environments and genetic backgrounds will be pivotal for LTG rice breeding. Furthermore, plant height is one of the important traits which should be considered in direct-seeding cultivation because tall rice plants are susceptible to lodging and resulting in decrease in yields. The previous studies reported that gibberellins (GAs) play important roles in seed germination, stem elongation, and flower development (Yamaguchi and Kamiya 2000; Olszewski et al. 2002). Recent studies demonstrated that genes involving in GA synthesis, OsGA20ox1, OsGA20ox2 and OsKO1 promotes germination and enhances plant height in rice (Abe et al. 2012; Ye et al. 2015; Zhang et al. 2020), while QTLs for seedling height and seed dormancy co-located with OsGA20ox1 (Abe et al. 2012) and OsGA20ox2 (Ye et al. 2015), respectively. Therefore, it could be possible that some LTG QTLs enhance seed germination under low temperature, and also contribute to increase in plant height, such QTLs could not be used in rice breeding for direct-seeding due to the risk of lodging.
In this study, we conducted GWAS of LTG using a subset of the Rice Diversity Panel 2 (sRDP2) consisting of 375 rice accessions, which has been genotyped by 700 K SNPs (McCouch et al. 2016). In total, eleven LTG QTLs were identified and located on chromosomes 1, 3, 4, 5, 7, 10 and 12. Among them, qLTG_sRDP2–10a on chromosome 10 had the largest contribution to LTG variations in 375 rice accessions. This QTL was further validated using single segment substitution line (SSSL) and its presence resulted in 59.8% increase in LTG under low temperature. It is noteworthy that three previous studies also mapped QTLs for LTG to the same regions as qLTG_sRDP2–10a (Jiang et al. 2006; Wang et al. 2018a, b). Through integrating differential expression and sequence variation analysis of the genes within the region of qLTG_sRDP2–10a between the rice accessions with high and low LTG, two candidate genes were identified. Since qLTG_sRDP2–10a was detected in five studies using different rice germplasm under different low temperatures, it could be a stably expressed QTL for LTG. The identification of qLTG_sRDP2–10a and its candidate genes provide a promising source for functional gene identification of LTG and molecular breeding for LTG in rice.
Variations of Low Temperature Germinability in sRDP2 Population
Phylogenetic analysis based on their genotypes determined by the 700 K SNPs (McCouch et al. 2016) demonstrated that the 375 rice accessions could be clustered into three groups, representing Indica (154 accessions), Japonica (147 accessions) and Aus (74 accessions) (Fig. S1A).
Large variations in LTG were observed in sRDP2 population under 13 °C low temperature (Table S1), ranging from 0 to 100.0%, with an average of 39.2% and a variation coefficient of 75.7%. The LTG distribution in 375 accessions was continuous, with more in the low LTG side (Fig. 1a). Seventy-eight accessions (20.8%) had LTG less than 10.0%, while 34 accessions (9.1%) had LTG more than 90.0% (Table S2). Particularly, the three accessions, DJOGOLON (accession 491, Indica), HONG ZUI ER (accession 517, Indica) and KHADASIYA 3 (accession 902, Aus) had LTG of 100%.
The LTG comparisons among different groups revealed that the LTG of Indica group was significantly higher than that of Japonica and Aus groups (p < 0.01), while the LTG of Japonica group was significantly higher than that of Aus group (p < 0.05) (Fig. 1b).
Identification and Mapping of QTLs for LTG Through GWAS
Based on the criteria of having less than 30% missing data and minor allele frequency (MAF) more than 5% in the sRDP2 population, 445,534 SNPs were selected for GWAS from the 700 K SNPs dataset in the Open Rice GWAS Platform (McCouch et al. 2016). Population structure of the sRDP2 estimated by Admixture software, principal component analysis (PCA) and kinship analysis suggested that there were three subpopulations in this panel, which are consistent to Indica, Japonica and Aus subpopulation (Fig. S1). Considering the effect of population structure on GWAS, three PCs were included in the mixed linear model (MLM) with kinship matrix when analyzing the whole population. The QQ plot and Manhattan plot of the GWAS results were showed in Fig. 2b and c. According to about 100 kb of the LD decay in 375 rice accessions (Fig. 2a), we delimited a QTL to a 200-kb region with center on the most significant SNP, in which there are three or more than three significant SNPs (p < 0.0001). Accordingly, nine QTLs with 35 significant SNPs were identified in the whole population (Fig. 2c). These QTLs distributed on chromosomes 1, 3, 4, 5, 7, 10, 12 and were designated as qLTG_sRDP2–1, qLTG_sRDP2–3, qLTG_sRDP2–4, qLTG_sRDP2–5, qLTG_sRDP2-7a, qLTG_sRDP2-7b, qLTG_sRDP2–10a, qLTG_sRDP2–10b and qLTG_sRDP2–12. Among the 9 QTLs, qLTG_sRDP2–3 and qLTG_sRDP2–12 located on chromosomes 3 and 12, respectively, are first reported in the present study, and the other seven QTLs co-localized with the previously identified LTG QTLs (Table 1). The QTL, qLTG_sRDP2–10a with the most significant SNP at 11,648,047 bp in the region of 11.55–11.75 Mb on chromosome 10 had the largest contribution to LTG variation in 375 rice accessions. It is noteworthy that this LTG QTL was also detected in the previous three studies using different rice germplasm under different low temperatures (Jiang et al. 2006; Wang et al. 2018a, b) (Table 1), suggesting that it is a stably expressed QTL for LTG.
GWAS was further conducted on the Indica, Aus and Japonica subpopulations and compared with all the identified QTLs (Fig. 3). In total, three and one QTLs were identified in the Aus and Japonica subpopulations, respectively, but none was identified in Indica subpopulation based on the criterion having more than three SNPs with the p < 0.0001 within 200-kb region. Comparisons of the QTLs identified in different subpopulations indicated that qLTG_JAP-3 from the Japonica subpopulation and qLTG_AUS-4 from the Aus subpopulation overlapped with qLTG_sRDP2–3 and qLTG_sRDP2–4 identified in the whole population, respectively, while qLTG_AUS-3 and qLTG_AUS-7 were only identified in the Aus subpopulation. qLTG_AUS-3 is also first reported in the present study (Fig. 3 and Table 1).
Validation of qLTG_sRDP2–10a Using Single Segment Substitution Line
Being stably expressed in different genetic background and cold environments, it is believed that qLTG_sRDP2–10a has a great potential value in rice breeding for LTG. To search for single segment substitution lines (SSSLs) for validation of qLTG_sRDP2–10a, haplotype analysis of qLTG_sRDP2–10a was performed and the haplotypes associated with high and low LTG were identified (Fig. 4a). The accessions with haplotype 2 (Hap2) had a LTG significantly higher than that with haplotype 1 (Hap1) (p < 0.01) (Fig. 4b). Based on the two haplotypes, we screened the rice SSSLs bank developed by Zhang et al. (2004) and identified Gangxiangnuo (GXN, donor parent carrying Hap2), Huajingxian74 (HJX74, recurrent parent carrying Hap1) and their derived SSSL S18 with a substitution segment in 10.99–11.96 Mb on chromosome 10 from GXN (Fig. 4c). The high LTG haplotype (Hap2) was found in GXN and S18, indicating that qLTG_sRDP2–10a exists in GXN and S18. Our previous study indicated that the two parents GXN and HJX74 exhibited significant difference in LTG, with 85.3% and 20.5% under 15 °C low temperature, respectively (Yang et al. 2017). In this study, the LTG assessments in two independent experiments showed that the LTG of S18 was 74.6% and 74.8%, respectively, also significantly higher than that of HJX74 with respective LTG 14.7% and 15.1% under 15 °C low temperature (p < 0.01) (Fig. 4d). Thus, qLTG_sRDP2–10a is validated and its presence could result in 59.8% increase in LTG under 15 °C low temperature. Further studies indicated that there is no significant difference in plant height between HJX74 and S18 (p > 0.05), with 112.0 cm and 112.5 cm, respectively (Fig. S2), suggesting that the introgression of qLTG_sRDP2–10a had no effect on the plant height.
Candidate Gene Analyses of qLTG_sRDP2–10a
The LD decay analysis in the QTL region indicated that an approximately 229 kb region (from 11.551 Mb to 11.780 Mb on chromosome 10) at the associated locus was the putative region for qLTG_sRDP2–10a (Fig. 5). Based on release 7 of the MSU Rice Genome Annotation Project on rice IRGSP-1.0 genome (http://rice.plantbiology.msu.edu/) (Kawahara et al. 2013), there are 29 genes annotated within the region of qLTG_sRDP2–10a. To cut down the number of candidate genes, we selected four lines consisting of two high LTG lines (accession 517 from sRDP2 and S18) and two low LTG lines (accession 86 from sRDP2 and HJX74) based on haplotype analysis, to conducted DNA re-sequencing and RNA-seq. Firstly, we analyzed the coding sequence variation of the 29 genes in the 4 lines. Taking Nipponbare genome sequence as reference, a total of 144 variations (SNP, deletion or insertion) in coding regions were found, and only 47 variations in four genes, LOC_Os10g22484, LOC_Os10g22510, LOC_Os10g22570 and LOC_Os10g22600 exhibited consistent sequence differences between the high and low LTG lines. The SNP between high and low LTG lines in LOC_Os10g22570 caused synonymous variation with no amino acid change, while the SNP in LOC_Os10g22600 causes missense mutation resulting in amino acid substitution. For 41 sequence variations in LOC_Os10g22484, nine SNPs caused synonymous mutation and the other 32 sequence variations caused amino acid substitutions. The four sequence variations in LOC_Os10g22510 also caused missense mutation and inframe deletion (Table S3, highlighted in yellow).
Simultaneously, gene differential expression analysis was conducted using these 4 lines, which were subjected to 13 °C low temperature treatment and sampled at 24 h after imbibition (T0) and 48 h (T1), 96 h (T2) and 144 h (T3) after cold treatment. RNA-seq revealed that 15 genes including LOC_Os10g22600 were not expressed during germination (data not shown). For the other 14 genes, the expression of LOC_Os10g22510 exhibited a similar pattern in high and low LTG lines. Only two genes, LOC_Os10g22484 and LOC_Os10g22520, were differentially expressed between the two pairs of contrasting lines (Fig. 6a and b, Fig. S3). These results were further confirmed by qRT-PCR assays (Fig. 6c and d). Taken together, LOC_Os10g22484 and LOC_Os10g22520 were considered as the candidate gene for qLTG_sRDP2–10a. However, the expression patterns of the two candidate genes were different. The expression levels of LOC_Os10g22484 in the high LTG lines were consistently significantly lower than that in the low LTG lines at all time points (p < 0.05), while LOC_Os10g22520 only exhibited differential expression between the two pairs of contrasting lines at 24 h imbibition (T0), at which the high LTG lines exhibited significantly higher gene expression levels than the low LTG lines (p < 0.05).
To find the cause of expression variation of the two genes during imbibition and low temperature treatment, we compared the sequence differences of the two genes between the two pairs of contrasting lines based on DNA re-sequencing of all 4 lines above. The sequence comparisons revealed that there were insertion and deletion sequence differences in the promoter and the intron region of LOC_Os10g22520 between the high and low LTG lines (Fig. 7c and Fig. S4), and an about 6 kb variation after 3969 bp at the 3′ end of LOC_Os10g22484 in the high LTG lines (Fig. 7a and Fig. S4).
To confirm the relationship between the sequence variation of two genes and the LTG, we further compared the sequence differences of the two genes between 10 high LTG rice accessions and 10 low LTG rice accessions selected based on haplotype analysis, including the 4 lines above. The primers used to amplify and sequence the target regions of the genes were designed based on the released sequence of Nipponbare (Table S4). For the gene LOC_Os10g22484, primers (D3F/D2R) spanning the variation joint were designed to amplify the target regions of the selected 20 rice accessions (Fig. 7a). The agarose gel electrophoresis revealed that there were clear target bands in all low LTG rice accessions, but no amplified target band was observed in the high LTG rice accessions (Fig. 7b), suggesting that the sequence variations exist in high LTG accessions. For LOC_Os10g22520, primers were designed to amplify the sequence between + 351 to − 443 (designated as 10gT1) (Fig. 7c). The sequence comparisons revealed that there were insertion and deletion sequence differences in LOC_Os10g22520 between the high and low LTG groups. A 239 bp or 256 bp insertion was observed at the position of − 179 in the promoter region of the high LTG rice accessions, while a 10 bp deletion was observed in the intron region (from the position of + 268 to + 277) in the low LTG rice accessions (Fig. 7d and Table S5).
The qLTG_sRDP2–10a Has a Great Potential Value in Rice Breeding
In the present study, a total of eleven LTG QTLs were identified through GWAS. Among these QTLs, three QTLs, qLTG_sRDP2–3/qLTG_JAP-3, qLTG_AUS-3 and qLTG_sRDP2–12 are first reported in the present study, and the other 8 QTLs overlap with or are adjacent to the previously identified LTG QTLs from different studies (Table 1), suggesting reliability of the results and the diversity of the rice germplasm in this study. Notably, qLTG_sRDP2–10a identified in the present study overlaps with the LTG QTLs identified in the previous three studies (Jiang et al. 2006; Wang et al. 2018a, b). In the study conducted by Jiang et al. (2006), they used a F2 population derived from USSR5 (japonica, high LTG) and N22 (indica, low LTG), and 15 °C low temperature for mapping of LTG QTL. They mapped qLTG-10 to 9.82–16.71 Mb on chromosome 10. Through GWAS, Wang et al. (2018a) identified a LTG QTL with the most significant SNP at the position of 11.57 Mb on chromosome 10 by using 187 rice accessions selected from the RDP1 under 12 °C low temperature. In another GWAS of LTG, Wang et al. (2018b) identified a LTG QTL with a significant SNP at the position of 11.89 Mb on chromosome 10 by using the Korean rice core set consisting of 137 accessions under 13 °C low temperature. Additionally, this QTL could be also detected using SSSL derived from GXN (high LTG) and HJX74 (low LTG) under 15 °C low temperature in the present study. Interestingly, qCTSR10–1 for cold tolerance at the bud bursting stage with the most significant marker at 11.03 Mb (Zhang et al. 2018) and qLTSS10–2 for cold tolerance at seedling stage with most significant marker at 11.62 Mb (Schläppi et al. 2017) were located in the same region as qLTG_sRDP2–10a. These QTLs located in the same region on the same chromosome might be attributed to the same QTL, pleiotropic effects of a gene, or the clustering of unrelated genes at this locus. Further studies are needed to elucidate these issues. But the same QTL for LTG was detected using different rice germplasm (USSR5, GXN, 375 rice accessions from RDP2, 187 rice accessions from RDP1, 137 accessions from Korean rice core set), different QTL detection approaches (bi-parental QTL analysis, GWAS and SSSL-based QTL analysis) and different low temperature conditions for cold treatment (12 °C for 10 days, 13 °C for 10 and 15 days, 15 °C for 10 and 13 days), suggesting that qLTG_sRDP2–10a is a stably expressed QTL for LTG. Moreover, qLTG_sRDP2–10a has the largest contribution to LTG variation in 375 rice accessions among the 9 LTG QTLs identified in the whole population. The SSSL-based QTL analysis indicated that the presence of qLTG_sRDP2–10a could result in 59.8% increase in LTG under 15 °C low temperature. Furthermore, our results suggest that qLTG_sRDP2–10a had no effect on the plant height, one of the main factors affecting lodging resistance in rice direct seeding practice. Large effect on LTG but no influence on plant height, and stable expression make qLTG_sRDP2–10a have a great potential value in rice breeding.
LOC_Os10g22484 and LOC_Os10g22520 Could Be the Candidate Genes Underlying qLTG_sRDP2–10a
The germination process of rice seeds is complex and can be divided into three stages: imbibition, germination and bud bursting. With absorbing water at the imbibition stage, the metabolism inside the seed becomes active. The storage substances are converted to soluble substances such as monosaccharide and amino acids, and transported to the embryo cells, leading to rapid division and elongation of the embryonic cells. When its volume increases to a certain extent, the embryo breaks through the seed coat and continues to grow. Therefore, the genes responsible for germination should be involved in these processes. In the present study, four of 29 putative genes in qLTG_sRDP2–10a region exhibited consistent sequence variations in the coding regions between the high and low LTG lines, and the sequence variations of three genes, LOC_Os10g22484, LOC_Os10g22510 and LOC_Os10g22600 cause amino acid substitutions. Gene differential expression analysis revealed that LOC_Os10g22600 were not expressed and the expression of LOC_Os10g22510 exhibited a similar pattern in high and low LTG lines. Only the two genes, LOC_Os10g22484 and LOC_Os10g22520 exhibited differential expression at 24 h after imbibition, and only LOC_Os10g22484 exhibited differential expression under 13 °C low temperature between the two pairs of lines with contrasting LTG (Fig. 6), suggesting that LOC_Os10g22520 is responsible for seed imbibition, while LOC_Os10g22484 is responsible for imbibition and germination at low temperatures. Furthermore, the sequence comparisons revealed a 239/256 bp insertion and 10 bp deletion in the promoter and the intron region of LOC_Os10g22520 between the high and low LTG lines, and about 6 kb variation at the 3′ end of LOC_Os10g22484 in the high LTG lines (Fig. 7). These results suggest that the sequence variations of LOC_Os10g22484 and LOC_Os10g22520 could be the cause for their differential expression in high and low LTG lines.
LOC_Os10g22520 encodes a glycoside hydrolase. Glycoside hydrolases are a class of enzymes that hydrolyze glycosidic bonds in various carbohydrate-containing compounds by endo- or exo-cleavage to form monosaccharides, oligosaccharides or glycoconjugates. It is reported that glycoside hydrolases participate in the degradation of cell wall polysaccharides, and are involved in the control of plant cell wall loosening: regulation of germination, growth and development, fruit ripening, abscission, and cell adhesion (Minic and Jouanin 2006; Minic 2008). In the present study, LOC_Os10g22520 exhibited significantly higher expression level in the high LTG lines than in low LTG lines, suggesting that it may be more active involvement in degradation of cell wall polysaccharides and cause tissue weakening, or involvement in carbohydrate mobilization to drive growth of the germinating embryo in high LTG lines, which consequently enhances their germinability at low temperature. LOC_Os10g22484 encodes a NBS-LRR domain containing protein. So far, very limited information is available for the function of LOC_Os10g22484. The genome-wide gene expression profiling indicated that this gene was involved in development of panicle in rice (Ke et al. 2018) and also responded to submergence in rice (Xiong et al. 2012). Many NBS-LRR domain containing proteins function in plant defense response against pathogens (Caplan et al. 2008). It has been reported that there are crosstalks and balancing trade-offs between biotic stress and abiotic stress responses (Ku et al. 2018; Berens et al. 2019). For instance, plants exposed to abiotic stresses such as high salinity and drought often display reduced immune activity (Bostock et al. 2014). It could be possible that the sequence variation of the NBS-LRR domain containing protein gene, LOC_Os10g22484 might result in increasing the germinability at low temperature in rice. To finalize the functions of these two genes on imbibitions and germination at low temperature in rice, transgenic experiments are underway.
Integrating GWAS and SSSL Can Facilitate Identification of QTL for Complex Traits in Rice
With the rapid development of genome sequencing technology, GWAS has been widely applied for dissection of complex traits in rice and proved to be an efficient approach for QTL analysis (Huang et al. 2010; McCouch et al. 2016). However, there always exist false positive results in GWAS due to improper population structure and statistical methods, poor quality of genotyping, or phenotyping errors. Therefore, it is a routine to confirm the target QTLs before they can be used for breeding practice or advanced to functional gene cloning. Bi-parental population, such as a F2 or BC population is normally developed for confirmation of the results from GWAS. But this approach is low efficient because it takes more time and manpower for population development and QTL analysis. In the present study, we employed SSSL-based QTL analysis for confirmation of qLTG_sRDP2–10a from GWAS. Firstly, we screened the parents of SSSLs based on the haplotype of the target QTL (qLTG_sRDP2–10a) and their phenotypes of the target trait (LTG), and identified the right parents GXN and HJX74; then, screened SSSLs derived from GXN and HJX74 and identified the target SSSL S18 based on haplotype and the QTL region. Finally, QTL mapping was conducted simply by comparing the difference in LTG between the target SSSL S18 and its recurrent parent HJX74. Using this approach, we were able to confirm the existence of qLTG_sRDP2–10a and its phenotypic effect. Compared with the bi-parental QTL analysis, it saves a lot of time for population development, genotyping and phenotyping. Furthermore, the SSSL is a permanent line, it can be used for repeatedly experiments which is particularly important for complex traits like LTG. Therefore, the SSSL-based QTL analyses could be a simple and accurate approach for identification of QTL, and also a good complementary approach for confirmation of the results from GWAS. Therefore, integrating GWAS and SSSL can facilitate identification of QTL for complex traits in rice.
In the present study, large LTG variations within 375 rice accessions from the RDP2 were observed, and the LTG of Indica group was significantly higher than that of Japonica and Aus groups (p < 0.01). Among the 11 LTG QTLs identified in this study, qLTG_sRDP2–10a had the largest contribution to LTG variations in 375 rice accessions and could be detected in five studies using different germplasm under different cold environments. Its large effect and stable expression make qLTG_sRDP2–10a particularly valuable in rice breeding. The two genes, LOC_Os10g22484 and LOC_Os10g22520 which exhibited differential expression and sequence variation between the high and low LTG lines were considered as the candidate genes underlying qLTG_sRDP2–10a. The sequence variations of the two genes could be the cause for their differential expression in high and low LTG lines. Our results suggest that integrating GWAS and SSSL can facilitate identification of QTL for complex traits in rice. The identification of qLTG_sRDP2–10a and its candidate genes provide a promising source for gene cloning of LTG and molecular breeding for LTG in rice.
A subset of the RDP2 (sRDP2) consisting of 375 rice accessions from 56 countries were used for GWAS in this study (Table S1). These rice accessions were selected from the Rice Diversity Panel 2 (RDP2) consisting of 1568 rice accessions based on their diversity and origins (McCouch et al. 2016).
Single segment substitution line (SSSL) used for qLTG_sRDP2–10a validation was developed by backcross and marker-assisted selection (Zhang et al. 2004; Xi et al. 2006). Each SSSL contains only one chromosomal segment from Gangxiangnuo (GXN, the donor parent with high LTG), and has the background of Huajingxian74 (HJX74, the recurrent parent with low LTG).
All seeds used for LTG experiments in this study were stored at room temperature for 3 months after harvested.
Evaluation of Low Temperature Germinabilty
Three replicates with 50 seeds per accession were adopted in evaluation of LTG in this study. The healthy and filled seeds were incubated at 49 °C for 96 h to break dormancy. After sterilized with 3% sodium hypochlorite solution, the seeds were soaked in distilled water for 24 h. Then, the soaked seeds were placed in a 7 cm petri dish with two layers of wet filter paper, and put into a growth chamber with a relative humidity of 80% for low temperature treatment for 10 days in dark. Low temperature of 13 °C and 15 °C were adopted in the sRDP2 and SSSLs, respectively. Emergence of plumule or radicle longer than 1 mm is considered as germination. The germination rates of the tested lines at low temperature (LT-GR) were estimated on the tenth day after cold treatment, and then the temperature in the growth chamber was increase to 30 °C for recovery. The germination rates of the tested lines at 30 °C (RT-GR) were estimated after 5 days. Low temperature germinability (LTG) of each line was expressed as the ratio of the germination rate at low temperature over the germination rate after recovery at 30 °C (LTG % = 100 x LT-GR / RT-GR).
GWAS of sRDP2 and QTL Delimitation
GWAS analysis was performed as described in our previous study (Zhao et al. 2018) by using software GAPIT version 2 (Tang et al. 2016) and HDRA dataset consisting of 700 K single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) (McCouch et al. 2016). SNPs were filtered by the criteria of having less than 30% missing data and minor allele frequency (MAF) > 0.05 (McCouch et al. 2016). In order to reduce the effect of population structure on GWAS, the mixed linear model (MLM) was selected in which the kinship matrix was used jointly with PC in GAPIT, and three PCs were included when analyzing across all subpopulations. Manhattan and QQ plots were produced using R package qqman (Turner 2018). A region having three or more than three significant SNPs (p < 0.0001) within 200 kb is considered as one QTL, which was used in previous studies (Shakiba et al. 2017;Wang et al. 2018a; Zhao et al. 2018; Jiang et al. 2019).
SSSL-Based QTL Analysis
The detection of QTL in SSSLs was performed as described in our previous study (Yang et al. 2016). When the difference in LTG between the SSSL and its recurrent parent HJX74 was significant at p<0.05 based on t-test, a QTL for LTG was declared.
Two high LTG accessions (517 from sRDP2 and S18) and two low LTG accessions (86 from sRDP2 and HJX74) were selected for RNA-sequencing based on haplotype analysis. Low temperature germination was conducted at 13 °C as described above. Sampling was done at 24 h after imbibition (T0), and 48 h (T1), 96 h (T2) and 144 h (T3) after cold treatment, respectively, with three biological replications. Total RNA was extracted from embryo (T0, T1 and T2) or embryo with coleoptile (T3) of germinating seed using Trizol reagent (Invitrogen, Carlsbad, CA, USA) and purified using RNeasy Plant Mini Kit (Qiagen, Valencia, CA). RNA-Seq was performed at Annoroad Gene Technology (Beijing, China), and data analysis was conducted using HISAT2-Stringtie-Deseq2 pipeline (Pertea et al. 2016). Raw counts of each sample exported from Stringtie were imported and normalized by DEseq2. Genes with read counts less than 10 in all samples were filtered out for further analysis. Then differentially expressed genes between two samples were identified according to the critiera of FDR ≤ 0.05 and estimated absolute log2 (FC) ≥ 1, which were exported from DEseq2 (Love et al. 2014).
Differential Expression Analysis of Genes by qRT-PCR
RNA reverse transcription reactions were performed using the PrimeScript TM RT reagent kit (Takara, Japan). The primers for qRT-PCR were designed by Primer Premier 5.0. Real-time PCR was carried out using the SYBR Premix ExTaq TM kit (Takara, Japan), following the manufacturer’s instructions, on a Biorad CFX 96 Real-Time System. The ubiquitin was used as endogenous normalized genes for mRNA. The same RNA samples used in RNA-Seq assays were used to confirm the results of RNA-Seq, and all reactions were run in triplicate. Primers used to amplify the selected genes are listed in Table S4.
The leaves of rice seedlings were collected and subjected to DNA extraction by the CTAB method. The experimental procedure was performed in accordance with standard protocols provided by Illumina company. The qualified genomic DNA was fragmented by ultrasonication, and then the fragmented DNA was subjected to fragment purification, terminal repair, 3′ end plus A, ligation and sequencing, and then fragmentation by agarose gel electrophoresis. The DNA size was selected and PCR amplification was performed to form a sequencing library. The constructed library was first subjected to library quality inspection, and the quality-qualified library was sequenced using Hiseq 4000(Illumina company, USA).
A phylogenetic tree of 375 rice accessions was constructed by MEGA 7.0 (Kumar et al. 2016) using SNP data mentioned above. The population structure of 375 rice accessions was constructed by Admixture v1.3.0 (http://software.genetics.ucla.edu/admixture/) using the appropriate format generated from PLink v1.9 (Shaun et al. 2007). Preset ancestry number (K, from one to nine) was applied to ancestry tracing analysis of these accessions. Pairwise relative kinship and PCA were generated in GAPIT version 2 (Tang et al. 2016). LD heatmap was drawn with Haploview (Barrett et al. 2005). A t-test was conducted using SAS (SAS Institute 2000) to detect the differences in LTG and expression levels of the candidate genes between the selected rice accessions.
Availability of Data and Materials
The datasets supporting the conclusions of this article are provided within the article and its additional files.
Low temperature germinability
Quantitative trait loci
Single segment substitution line
Genome-wide association study
Minor allele frequency
Nucleotide binding site-leucine rich repeat
Rice Diversity Panel 2
Abe A, Takagi H, Fujibe T, Aya K, Kojima M, Sakakibara H, Uemura A, Matsuoka M, Terauchi R (2012) OsGA20ox1, a candidate gene for a major QTL controlling seedling vigor in rice. Theor Appl Genet 125:647–657
Barrett J, Fry B, Maller J, Daly M (2005) Haploview: analysis and visualization of LD and haplotype maps. Bioinformatics 21(2):263–265
Berens M, Wolinska K, Spaepen S, Ziegler J, Nobori T, Nair A, Krüler V, Winkelmüller T, Wang Y, Mine A, Becker D, Garrido-Oter R, Schulze-Lefert P, Tsuda K (2019) Balancing trade-offs between biotic and abiotic stress responses through leaf age-dependent variation in stress hormone cross-talk. Proc Natl Acad Sci 116(6):2364–2373
Borjas A, De L, Subudhi P (2016) Genetic analysis of germinating ability and seedling vigor under cold stress in US weedy rice. Euphytica 208:251–264
Bostock R, Pye M, Roubtsova T (2014) Predisposition in plant disease: exploiting the nexus in abiotic and biotic stress perception and response. Annu Rev Phytopathol 52:517–549
Caplan J, Padmanabhan M, Dinesh-Kumar S (2008) Plant NB-LRR immune receptors from recognition to transcriptional reprogramming. Cell Host Microbe 3(3):126–135
Fujino K, Obara M, Shimizu T, Koyanagi K, Ikegaya T (2015) Genome-wide association mapping focusing on a rice population derived from rice breeding programs in a region. Breed Sci 65:403–410
Fujino K, Sekiguchi H, Matsuda Y, Sugimoto K, Ono K, Yano M (2008) Molecular identification of a major quantitative trait locus, qLTG3-1, controlling low-temperature germinability in rice. Proc Natl Acad Sci 105:12623–12628
Fujino K, Sekiguchi H, Sato T, Kiuchi H, Nonoue Y, Takeuchi Y, Ando T, Lin S, Yano M (2004) Mapping of quantitative trait loci controlling low-temperature germinability in rice (Oryza sativa L.). Theor Appl Genet 108:794–799
Han L, Zhang Y, Qiao Y, Cao G, Zhang S, KIM J, Koh H (2006) Genetic and QTL analysis for low-temperature vigor of germination in rice. Acta Genet Sin 33(11):998–1006
Huang X, Wei X, Sang T, Zhao Q, Feng Q, Zhao Y, Li C, Zhu C, Lu T, Zhang Z, Li M, Fan D, Guo Y, Wang A, Wang L, Deng L, Li W, Lu Y, Weng Q, Liu K, Huang T, Zhou T, Jing Y, Li W, Lin Z, Buckler E, Qian Q, Zhang Q, Li J, Han B (2010) Genome-wide association studies of 14 agronomic traits in rice landraces. Nat Genet 42:961–967
Jiang L, Liu S, Hou M, Tang J, Chen L, Zhai H, Wan J (2006) Analysis of QTLs for seed low temperature germinability and anoxia germinability in rice (Oryza sativa L.). Field Crop Res 98:68–75
Jiang N, Shi S, Shi H, Khanzada H, Wassan G, Zhu C, Peng X, Yu Q, Chen X, He X, Fu J, Hu L, Xu J, Ouyang L, Sun X, Zhou D, He H, Bian J (2017) Mapping QTL for seed germinability under low temperature using a new high-density genetic map of rice. Front Plant Sci 8:1223
Jiang S, Wang D, Yan S, Liu S, Liu B, Kang H, Wang G (2019) Dissection of the genetic architecture of rice tillering using a genome-wide association study. Rice 12:43
Kawahara Y, de la Bastide M, Hamilton J, Kanamori H, McCombie W, Ouyang S, Schwartz D, Tanaka T, Wu J, Zhou S, Childs K, Davidson R, Lin H, Quesada-Ocampo L, Vaillancourt B, Sakai H, Lee S, Kim J, Numa H, Itoh T, Buell C, Matsumoto T (2013) Improvement of the Oryza sativa Nipponbare reference genome using next generation sequence and optical map data. Rice 6:4
Ke S, Liu X, Luan X, Yang W, Zhu H, Liu G, Zhang G, Wang S (2018) Genome-wide transcriptome profiling provides insights into panicle development of rice. Gene 675:285–300
Ku Y, Sintaha M, Cheung M, Lam H (2018) Plant hormone signaling crosstalks between biotic and abiotic stress responses. Int J Mol Sci 19:3206
Kumar S, Stecher G, Tamura K (2016) MEGA7: molecular evolutionary genetics analysis version 7.0 for bigger datasets. Mol Biol Evol 33:1870–1874
Li L, Liu X, Xie K, Wang Y, Liu F, Lin Q, Wang W, Yang C, Lu B, Liu S, Chen L, Jiang L, Wan J (2013) qLTG-9, a stable quantitative trait locus for low-temperature germination in rice (Oryza sativa L.). Theor Appl Genet 126:2313–2322
Love M, Huber W, Anders S (2014) Moderated estimation of fold change and dispersion for RNA-seq data with DESeq2. Genome Biol 15(12):550
Mahender A, Anandan A, Pradhan S (2015) Early seedling vigour, an imperative trait for direct-seeded rice: an overview on physio-morphological parameters and molecular markers. Planta 241:1027–1050
McCouch S, Wright M, Tung C, Maron L, McNally K, Fitzgerald M, Singh N, DeClerck G, Agosto-Perez F, Korniliev G, Naredo M, Harrington S, Shi Y, Branchini D, Kuser-Falcao P, Leung H, Ebana K, Yano M, Eizenga G, McClung A, Mezey J (2016) Open access resources for genome-wide association mapping in rice. Nat Commun 7:10532
Minic Z (2008) Physiological roles of plant glycoside hydrolases. Planta 227(4):723–740
Minic Z, Jouanin L (2006) Plant glycoside hydrolases involved in cell wall polysaccharide degradation. Plant Physiol Biochem 44:435–449
Miura K, Lin S, Yano M, Nagamine T (2001) Mapping quantitative trait loci controlling low temperature germinability in rice (Oryza sativa L.). Breed Sci 51:293–299
Olszewski N, Sun T, Gubler F (2002) Gibberellin signaling: biosynthesis, catabolism, and response pathways. Plant Cell 14:S61–S80
Pan Y, Zhang H, Zhang D, Li J, Xiong H, Yu J, Li J, Rehman R, Li G, Ma X, Cao G, Han L, Li Z (2015) Genetic analysis of cold tolerance at the germination and booting stages in rice by association mapping. PLoS One 10(3):e0120590
Pertea M, Kim D, Pertea G, Leek J, Salzberg S (2016) Transcript-level expression analysis of RNA-seq experiments with HISAT, StringTie and Ballgown. Nat Protoc 11(9):1650–1659
Ranawake A, Manangkilb O, Yoshidac S, Ishiid T, Morie N, Nakamurae C (2014) Mapping QTLs for cold tolerance at germination and the early seedling stage in rice (Oryza sativa L.). Biotechnol Biotechnol Equip 28(6):989–998
Saito K, Hayano-Saito Y, Kuroki M, Sato Y (2010) Map-based cloning of the rice cold tolerance gene Ctb1. Plant Sci 179(1–2):97–102
Sales E, Viruel J, Domingo C, Marque’s L (2017) Genome wide association analysis of cold tolerance at germination in temperate japonica rice (Oryza sativa L.) varieties. PLoS One 12(8):e0183416
SAS Institute (2000) SAS/STAT user’s guide, version 8.1. SAS Institute Inc, Cary
Satoh T, Tezuka K, Kawamoto T, Matsumoto S, Satoh N, Ueda K, Sakurai K, Watanabe A, Takahashi H, Akagi H (2016) Identification of QTLs controlling low-temperature germination of the east European rice (Oryza sativa L.) variety Maratteli. Euphytica 207:245–254
Schläppi M, Jackson A, Eizenga G, Wang A, Chu C, Shi Y, Shimoyama N, Boykin D (2017) Assessment of five chilling tolerance traits and GWAS mapping in rice using the USDA Mini-Core collection. Front Plant Sci 8:957
Shakiba E, Edwards J, Jodari F, Duke S, Baldo A, Korniliev P, McCouch S, Eizenga G (2017) Genetic architecture of cold tolerance in rice (Oryza sativa L.) determined through high resolution genome-wide analysis. PLoS One 12(3):e0172133
Shaun P, Benjamin N, Kathe T, Lori T, Manuel A, David B, Maller J, Pamela S, Paul I, Mark J, Pak C (2007) PLINK: a tool set for whole genome association and population based linkage analyses. Am J Hum Genet 81:559–575
Singh K, Kumar V, Saharawat Y, Gathala M, Ladha J, Chauhan B (2013) Weedy rice: an emerging threat for direct-seeded rice production systems in India. J Rice Res 1:106
Tang Y, Liu X, Wang J, Li M, Wang Q, Tian F, Su Z, Pan Y, Liu D, Lipkai A, Buckler E, Zhang Z (2016) GAPIT version 2: an enhanced integrated tool for genomic association and prediction. Plant Genome 9:2
Turner SD (2018) qqman: an R package for visualizing GWAS results using Q-Q and manhattan plots. J Open Source Softw 3(25):731
Wang H, Lee A, Park S, Jin S, Lee J, Ham T, Park Y, Zhao W, Kwon S (2018b) Genome-wide association study reveals candidate genes related to low temperature tolerance in rice (Oryza sativa L.) during germination. 3 Biotech 8:235
Wang X, Zou B, Shao Q, Cui Y, Lu S, Zhang Y, Huang Q, Huang J, Hua J (2018a) Natural variation reveals that OsSAP16 controls low-temperature germination in rice. J Exp Bot 69(3):413–421
Wang Z, Wang F, Zhou R, Wang J, Zhang H (2011) Identification of quantitative trait loci for cold tolerance during the germination and seedling stages in rice (Oryza sativa L.). Euphytica 181:405–413
Xi Z, He F, Zeng R, Zhang Z, Ding X, Li W, Zhang G (2006) Development of a wide population of chromosome single-segment substitution lines in the genetic background of an elite cultivar of rice (Oryza sativa L.). Genome 49(5):476–484
Xiong H, Yang J, Li Y. (2012) Identication of submergence-responsive genes in two indica rice genotypes carrying SUB1A- but exhibiting differential tolerance. J Plant Biol 55:233–41
Yamaguchi S, Kamiya Y (2000) Gibberellin biosynthesis: its regulation by endogenous and environmental signals. Plant Cell Physiol 41(3):251–257
Yang T, Zhang S, Wang X, Dong J, Huang Z, Zhao J, Liu Q, Mao X, Zhang G, Liu B (2017) Evaluation of cold tolerance at four growth stages and analysis of relationship between cold tolerance and indica-japonica differentiation in a diverse rice collection (Oryza Sativa L.). Mol Plant Breed 15(2):763–773 (In Chinese with English abstract)
Yang T, Zhang S, Zhao J, Liu Q, Huang Z, Mao X, Dong J, Wang X, Zhang G, Liu B (2016) Identification and pyramiding of QTLs for cold tolerance at the bud bursting and the seedling stages by use of single segment substitution lines in rice (Oryza sativa L.). Mol Breed 36:96
Ye H, Feng J, Zhang L, Zhang J, Mispan M, Cao Z, Beighley D, Yang J, Gu X (2015) Map-based cloning of Seed Dormancy1-2 identified a gibberellin synthesis gene regulating the development of endosperm-imposed dormancy in rice. Plant Physiol 169(3):2152–2165
Yu J, Buckler E (2006) Genetic association mapping and genome organization of maize. Curr Opin Biotechnol 17:155–160
Zhang G, Zeng R, Zhang Z, Ding X, Li W, Liu G, He F, Talukdar A, Huang C, Xi Z, Qin L, Shi J, Zhao F, Feng M, Shan Z, Chen L, Guo X, Zhu H, Lu Y (2004) The construction of a library of single segment substitution lines in rice (Oryza sativa L.). Rice Genet Newsl 21:85–87
Zhang H, Li M, He D, Wang K, Yang P (2020) Mutations on ent-kaurene oxidase 1 encoding gene attenuate its enzyme activity of catalyzing the reaction from ent-kaurene to ent-kaurenoic acid and lead to delayed germination in rice. PLoS Genet 16(1):e1008562
Zhang M, Ye J, Xu Q, Feng Y, Yuan X, Yu H, Wang Y, Wei X, Yang Y (2018) Genome-wide association study of cold tolerance of Chinese indica rice varieties at the bud burst stage. Plant Cell Rep 37:529–539
Zhao J, Yang W, Zhang S, Yang T, Liu Q, Dong J, Fu H, Mao X, Liu B (2018) Genome-wide association study and candidate gene analysis of rice cadmium accumulation in grain in a diverse rice collection. Rice 11:61
The seeds of the 375 rice accessions in the present study were provided by International Rice Research Institute. The SSSLs and its parents were provided by Professor Guiquan Zhang in South China Agricultural University.
This study was partially supported by the Scientific and Technological Plan of Guangzhou (201804020078), the Innovation Team Project of Guangdong Modern Agricultural Industrial System (2018LM2150, 2019KJ106), the Guangdong-Hong Kong Joint Project (2017A050506035), the Guangdong Provincial Scientific and Technological Plan (2017A020208022), Guangdong Basic and Applied Basic Research Foundation (2020A1515011051) and the Special Fund of Central Government Guided Local Scientific Development.
Ethics Approval and Consent to Participate
Consent for Publication
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Population structure analysis of sRDP2 consisting of 375 rice accessions. A, Clustering of the 375 rice accessions according to their genotypes determined by 700 K SNPs. B, Genetic structure of sRDP2. Subgroups (K = 3) inferred using Admixture software. C, Pair-wise plots of principal component analysis of sRDP2. D, The heat map of pair-wise relative kinship analysis of sRDP2.
The plant height of HJX74 and S18 in the field. The observation value was the average of three replicates, with 20 plants in each replicate.
Temporal expression patterns of the other 12 putative genes within the region of qLTG-sRDP2–10a measured by RNA-seq. T0 represents imbibition for 24 h; T1, T2 and T3 represent 13 °C cold treatment for 48 h, 96 h and 144 h, respectively.
Gene structure variation analysis of LOC_Os10g22484 and LOC_Os10g22520 based on the DNA re-sequencing.
The LTG and information of 375 rice accessions.
The rice accessions with LTG over 90%.
The coding sequence variation analysis of genes located in qLTG_sRDP2–10a region between high LTG lines (517 and S18) and low LTG lines (HJX74 and 86) based on DNA re-sequencing.
Primer sequences used in this study.
Sequence differences of 10gT1 in LOC_Os10g22520 between high and low LTG rice accessions.
About this article
Cite this article
Yang, T., Zhou, L., Zhao, J. et al. The Candidate Genes Underlying a Stably Expressed QTL for Low Temperature Germinability in Rice (Oryza sativa L.). Rice 13, 74 (2020). https://doi.org/10.1186/s12284-020-00434-z
- Rice (Oryza sativa L.)
- Low temperature germinability
- Quantitative trait locus
- Candidate gene
- Genome-wide association study