- Open Access
Characterization of Domestication Loci Associated with Awn Development in Rice
Rice volume 15, Article number: 61 (2022)
Rice (Oryza sativa L.) is a widely studied domesticated model plant. Seed awning is an unfavorable trait during rice harvesting and processing. Hence, loss of awn was one of the target characters selected during domestication. However, the genetic mechanisms underlying awn development in rice are not well understood. In this study, we analyzed and characterized the genes for awn development using a mapping population derived from a cross between the Korean indica cultivar ‘Milyang23’ and a near-isogenic line NIL4/9 derived from a cross between ‘Hwaseong’ and Oryza minuta. Two quantitative trait loci (QTLs), qAwn4 and qAwn9, mapped on chromosomes 4 and 9, respectively, increased awn length in an additive manner. Through comparative sequencing analyses of the parental lines, LABA1 was determined as the causal gene underlying qAwn4. qAwn9 was mapped to a 199-kb physical region between markers RM24663 and RM24679. Within this interval, 27 annotated genes were identified, and five genes, including a basic leucine zipper transcription factor 76 (OsbZIP76), were considered as candidate genes for qAwn9 based on their functional annotations and sequence variations. Haplotype analysis using the candidate gene revealed tropical-japonica specific sequence variants in the qAwn9 region, which partly explains the non-detection of qAwn9 in previous studies that used progenies from interspecific crosses. This provides further evidence that OsbZIP76 is possibly a causal gene for qAwn9. The O. minuta qAwn9 allele was identified as a major QTL, providing an important molecular target for understanding the genetic control of awn development in rice. Our results lay the foundation for further cloning of the awn gene underlying qAwn9.
Cereal crops have been the principal component of human diets for thousands of years, with the most highly productive crops (rice, wheat, and maize) contributing to more than half of the calories consumed (Awika 2011). Despite the critical importance of these crops, their history of cultivation is poorly understood, and their origin is still debated even after intensive studies (Doebley et al. 2006; Sweeney and McCouch 2007). Domestication was conducted through selection driven by human that considerably changed the morpho-physiological characteristics of wild species to facilitate efficient farming, harvesting, and consumption (Tang et al. 2010). To satisfy the growing human demand, some important traits, such as easy harvest, high yield, and low toxicity, are preferred during the selection process. The presence of awns, an unfavorable characteristic during harvest and processing, has been targeted by selection programs (Ishii and Ishikawa 2018). The loss of awn in some cereals, including cultivated rice (Oryza sativa L.), is a prominent example of domestication (Hua et al. 2015). Plant adaptation has facilitated the presence of awns in many wild rice species to protect against animal predation and to facilitate the motility required for seed dispersal (Elbaum et al. 2007; Yoshioka et al. 2017). In contrast, through artificial selection and breeding programs, rice domestication has led to cultivated rice with shorter, or even without, awns that facilitate seed collection, storage, and processing by humans.
Considerable interest exists in discovering genes and genetic mechanisms contributing to awn reduction during domestication because it may facilitate basic research and trait manipulation through breeding strategies (Bessho-Uehara et al. 2021; Ross-Ibarra et al. 2007). Moreover, rice domestication initially resulted from selection on natural mutations in wild rice. Therefore, identifying domestication genes using interspecific crossing is an effective and accurate way to provide sufficient evidence to understand the rice domestication process. Additionally, wild rice species are not only important resources for rice breeding but also provide a potential opportunity for identifying novel genes (Solis et al. 2020).
Recently, studies have been conducted to elucidate the genetic mechanisms underlying the development of rice awns. These results suggest that awn development is a complex trait regulated by many genes and is mostly observed in wild rice (Bessho-Uehara et al. 2021; Amarasinghe et al. 2020; Qin et al. 2021; Wang et al. 2011). Although several awn-related quantitative trait loci (QTLs) have been detected, only a few major QTLs have been cloned and characterized at the molecular level. An-1 encodes a basic helix–loop–helix (bHLH) transcription factor that regulates cell division, promotes awn development, and reduces the grain number (Luo et al. 2013). An-2/LABA1 (LABA1) encodes a critical enzyme for cytokinin biosynthesis that promotes awn elongation by enhancing cell division and decreasing grain production, through reducing the number of grains per panicle and tillers per plant (Gu et al. 2015; Hua et al. 2015). RAE2/GAD1/GLA (RAE2) encodes a secreted peptide, and the loss of function of RAE2 results in an increased number of grains per panicle, shorter grains, and an awnless phenotype (Bessho-Uehara et al. 2016; Jin et al. 2016; Zhang et al. 2019). The auxin response factor OsETT2 and the YABBY transcription factor DROOPING LEAF (DL) are related to awn formation (Toriba and Hirano 2014). Although these studies have improved our understanding of the genetic basis of awn development, the molecular mechanism for the transformation of wild rice long awns to awnless cultivated rice remains poorly understood. Furthermore, the genes isolated to date have a substantial effect on awn development. These have created an intense desire to increase efforts to identify and clone the remaining genes with smaller effects.
Our previous study detected qAwn9 for awn development near the simple sequence repeat (SSR) marker RM215 on chromosome 9 (Linh et al. 2006). However, phenotypic data of the F2 population suggested that at least two genes controlling awn length in the cross combination. It is impossible to detect other awn-related genes because this F2 population is segregated only in the region containing the Oryza minuta segment.
To continue our previous study, the objectives of this present study were: (1) to confirm and specify the target region containing QTL associated with awn length on chromosome 9 using a BC1F2 population derived from a new cross between the Korean indica cultivar ‘Milyang23’ and NIL4/9, (2) detect the other QTLs in addition to qAwn9 that are associated with awn development in the population, (3) investigate the genetic interaction between the discovered QTLs, and (4) to determine the candidate gene for qAwn9.
Materials and Methods
A near-isogenic line, NIL4/9, harboring an O. minuta (IRGC No. 101141) segment on chromosome 9 was selected from the BC8F4 population derived from a cross between O. minuta and Hwaseongbyeo (hereinafter Hwaseong) in a previous study (Linh et al. 2006). To identify the QTLs influencing awn development in NIL4/9 and japonica cultivar Hwaseong, a cross was made between the Korean indica cultivar Milyang23 (awnless phenotype) and NIL4/9 (long awn) (Fig. 1). The F2 population (840 plants) derived from F1 plants was used to detect additional QTLs other than qAwn9. To detect QTLs, two contrasting phenotypic groups, each with 11 long-awned and 11 awnless Milyang23 homozygous F2 plants at qAwn9, were screened, and one additional major QTL, qAwn4, was observed. Based on the genotypes at two major QTLs, qAwn4 and qAwn9, one long-awned F2 plant, CR7017-9, with homozygous NIL4/9 alleles at qAwn4 and qAwn9, was selected and backcrossed with Milyang23 (Fig. 2A). By selfing the BC1F1 plants, 900 BC1F2 individuals were generated for QTL confirmation, fine mapping, and genetic interaction analysis.
Field Experiments and Phenotyping
Germinated seeds were first sown in trays, placed under greenhouse conditions and then moved outdoors for one week before transplanting. At 28 days after sowing, seedlings (one plant per hill) were transplanted at a distance of 15 cm between plants within a row and 30 cm between rows. All plant materials (crossing and natural populations) were grown in a bird-net-equipped field at Chungnam National University, Daejeon, South Korea. Plants with awns longer than 1 mm were used to measure the length with a millimeter ruler, while the others were considered awnless phenotypes. Three main panicles were collected from each plant for phenotyping. The average awn length of the apical spikelets on each primary branch was used to represent the awn length of the whole panicle.
Analysis of QTL and Interaction Analysis for Seed Awning
QTL analysis for seed awning was conducted using a BC1F2 population to confirm the linkage between the candidate markers and awn QTLs. To minimize the influence of putative QTLs on each other, two subgroups, Pop-4 and Pop-9, were selected based on the genotypes of 900 BC1F2 plants at two QTLs, qAwn4 and qAwn9, respectively (Fig. 2B). In Pop-4, all plants segregated at qAwn4 and were Milyang23 homozygous at qAwn9. All the plants in Pop-9 segregated at qAwn9, and were Milyang23 homozygous at qAwn4. A putative QTL was estimated using single marker analysis or interval marker analysis based on one-way ANOVA followed by Tukey’s test. Additionally, a single plant heterozygous for the putative QTL was selected and selfed in each subgroup. QTL analysis for seed awning was repeated using BC1F3 populations to confirm the QTL detection.
To determine the interaction between qAwn4 and qAwn9, four homozygous genotypes (G11, G13, G31, and G33) from the BC1F2 population were selected using three markers (RM252 for qAwn4 and RM201 and RM24751 for qAwn9). G11 was homozygous for Milyang23 at qAwn4 and qAwn9, whereas G13 was homozygous for Milyang23 at qAwn4 and O. minuta at qAwn9. In addition, G31 was homozygous for Hwaseong at qAwn4 and Milyang23 at qAwn9, and G33 was homozygous for Hwaseong at qAwn4 and O. minuta at qAwn9. For each genotype G11, G13, G31, and G33, ten BC1F2 plants were selected to account for possible background effects. Moreover, the awn length of ten BC1F3 lines (21 plants per line) in each group was evaluated to confirm the genetic interactions (Fig. 2C).
DNA Extraction and Genotype Analysis
Total DNA was extracted from fresh leaves using the CTAB method described by (Murray and Thompson 1980). The polymerase chain reactions (PCR) were carried out in a 15-μL reaction volume containing 2-μL of diluted genomic DNA, 0.15-μL of 5.0 U/μL Taq DNA polymerase (Elpis), 1.5-μLl of dNTP Mix (2.5 uM each), 1.5-μL of Primers mix (10 pmol/μL), 1.5-μL of 10X PCR buffer, and 8.35 μL of ddH2O. The amplified products were electrophoresed on a 3% high-resolution MetaPhor agarose gel (Lonzan, Rockland, ME, USA) or a 4% polyacrylamide denaturing gel, depending on the band separation of the markers. The same procedure was used for genotyping all materials in this study. Markers used to analyze the two awn QTLs, and fine-map qAwn9 are described (Additional file 2: Table S1).
Genome-Wide Association Study (GWAS)
The qAwn9 was firstly detected by using a population derived from interspecific cross between O. sativa and wild rice O. minuta. However, we were interested in knowing whether or not the association between qAwn9 and awn length variation also existed in natural population of cultivated rice O. sativa. We performed GWAS using the sequence information of 137 accessions in the KRICE_CORE set listed in Additional file 2: Table S2 and the method described in a previous study (Kim et al. 2016). Association analysis for awn development was performed using the compressed mixed linear model (MLM) method using GAPIT, where the PCA and relative kinship matrices were defined as fixed and random effects. Significant single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) were identified at a significance threshold of -log10(p) > 6.0.
High-Throughput Whole-Genome Sequencing
High-throughput whole-genome sequencing was performed on three parental lines, NIL4/9, Hwaseong, and Milyang23. Whole-genome sequencing was performed by Macrogen Inc. (Beotkkot-ro, Geumcheon-gu, Seoul, South Korea). Test-qualified genomic DNA samples were used to construct shotgun DNA libraries using the TruSeq Nano DNA Kit (San Diego, California 92,122, USA) and were sequenced using HiSeq X Ten. The project result is summarized in Additional file 2: Table S3.
Analysis of Candidate Genes
Potential candidate genes were shortlisted based on SNPs and insertions/deletions (InDels) in the promoter and exon regions between parental lines. Haplotype analysis was performed on the most likely candidate genes using all SNPs within the gene coding sequence region, in which synonymous SNPs were ignored. Phenotypic differences between the haplotypes were estimated in the KRICE_CORE set based on the t-test (n > 5 rice accessions). Additionally, the sequence information of 36 Oryza rufipogon accessions was downloaded from the TASUKE database (Additional file 2: Table S4, https://rapdb.dna.affrc.go.jp).
Genetic Background of NIL4/9
To detect O. minuta segments in NIL4/9, 212 SSR markers distributed across the 12 rice chromosomes were screened between Hwaseong and NIL4/9. Consequently, with several continuous backcross generations combining marker-assisted selection, one O. minuta segment was detected by three markers, RM24663, RM24730, and VNR10, on chromosome 9, which overlapped with the region in our previous study (Fig. 3). Notably, two markers, RM24663 and VNR10, produced polymorphic bands in the three parental lines. Furthermore, when the F2 population was screened with these two markers, all F2 plants carried the O. minuta segment and/or Milyang23, whereas no Hwaseong segment-carrying plants were detected (Additional file 1: Fig. S1). These results further confirmed the presence of O. minuta segment in the NIL4/9 background.
First Signature of Multiple QTLs Associated with Awn Length
NIL4/9 was generated by repeated backcrossing with selection for introgression of an O. minuta segment into the Hwaseong background. On average, the awn length of NIL4/9 was 13.30 ± 1.46 mm, and that of Hwaseong was 5.50 ± 0.99 mm. Compared to Hwaseong, NIL4/9 showed significantly longer awns, suggesting that NIL4/9 carried additional genes/QTLs associated with seed awning; one was qAwn9, detected in our previous study, and the other genes were possibly segregated in the Hwaseong background. This hypothesis is consistent with the phenotypic data of the F2 population (derived from a cross between Milyang23 and NIL4/9) that qAwn9 alone cannot explain the variation in awn phenotypes.
To detect additional QTLs for awn development, 54 polymorphic markers between NIL4/9 and Milyang23 were selected out of 212 markers (Fig. 3). Two contrasting phenotypic groups, each with 11 long-awned and 11 awnless Milyang23 homozygous F2 plants at qAwn9, were screened using 54 markers. Genotype analysis showed that at RM252 on chromosome 4, eight long-awned plants and all 11 awnless plants were homozygous for the Hwaseong and Milyang23 alleles, respectively, and three long-awned plants were heterozygous (χ2 = 22, p < 0.001), implying that RM252 is likely to be linked to the causal QTL controlling awn development in this population (Additional file 1: Fig. S2). However, the other markers failed to show consistent polymorphic patterns between the two groups (ID-J, χ2 = 1.81, p = 0.40; RM525, χ2 = 0.40; p = 0.82), suggesting that these markers were not linked to the additional QTL. Hence, RM252 was used as a marker to analyze additional QTL. Considering that this procedure only allows for approximate mapping of the QTL, further mapping analysis using a backcross population was conducted.
QTL Analysis for Seed Awning
QTL analysis for seed awning was conducted using BC1F2 individuals to confirm the two respective QTLs. One was linked to RM252 on chromosome 4 (qAwn4), and the other was located on chromosome 9 showing linkage to two markers, RM201 and RM24751 (qAwn9) (Table 1 and Additional file 1: Fig. S3). qAwn4 accounted for 19.1% of total phenotypic variation. qAwn9 was further confirmed in this study and accounted for 14.6% of phenotypic variation. QTL analysis was conducted using BC1F3 progenies to confirm the accuracy of QTL detection. Both QTLs were repeatedly detected in two consecutive years, and qAwn4 and qAwn9 accounted for 21.6% and 20.0% of phenotypic variation, respectively. These results confirmed that both QTLs had a major effect (R2 > 14%) and that awn length is a complex quantitative trait controlled by multiple genes and the environment. Additionally, the awn length of the heterozygotes was intermediate between that of the two homozygotes, indicating that Hwaseong and O. minuta alleles act additively at qAwn4 and qAwn9, respectively.
Interestingly, qAwn4 overlapped with the well-known gene LABA1. Therefore, sequencing analyses of the parental lines were conducted to determine whether LABA1 in the QTL region was the causal gene for qAwn4 in this population. Notably, the previously known functional variation of LABA1, a 1-bp deletion at + 69-bp in the first exon, was discovered (Additional file 1: Fig. S4, (Hua et al. 2015)). Therefore, qAwn4 is designated as LABA1 hereinafter. Furthermore, based on the genetic background of NIL4/9, we determined that the O. minuta qAwn9 allele and the Hwaseong LABA1 allele contributed to an increase in awn length, whereas Milyang23 had nonfunctional alleles at both loci.
Interaction Between LABA1 and qAwn9
In this study, two QTLs were detected for awn length, and their interaction with seed awning was further examined. Analysis indicated a significant interaction between LABA1 and qAwn9 (p = 0.028) (Table 1). To characterize the interaction between LABA1 and qAwn9, four different combinations of homozygous genotypes (G11, G13, G31, and G33) were compared in terms of awn length. The average awn lengths of the four genotypes were significantly different (Fig. 4). G11 plants (with Milyang23 homozygous alleles at both loci) had no or tip awn, whereas awn formation and elongation were observed in plants with functional alleles at one of the two loci. The awns of the G13 and G31 plants (having the functional allele at qAwn9 or LABA1) were significantly longer than those of the G11 plants. This result indicates that both loci can independently induce awns. The longest awns were observed in G33 plants, with functional alleles at both loci. The interaction was also observed for awn length when ten BC1F3 lines (21 plants per line) of each group were evaluated. The awn length in each group showed a wide range of variation, especially in BC1F2, probably because of the difference in the genetic background of the individual BC1F2 plants used to measure awn length. Compared to the BC1F2 plants, the variation in awn length was reduced in the BC1F3 line. Moreover, the possibility that some minor QTLs segregated in the population could not be ruled out because only the large-effect qAwn4 was detected using two extreme phenotype groups in the F2 population derived from a cross between Milyang23 and NIL4/9. Altogether, qAwn9 and LABA1 behaved additively during awn development and showed a stable and major effect in Milyang23 (indica) and Hwaseong (japonica) backgrounds.
Identification of Genomic Regions Associated with Awn Length in the Natural Population
GWAS analysis identified 16 genomic regions (designated as QTLs) tagged with 48 significant SNPs. These SNPs were localized on chromosomes 1, 2, 3, 4, 7, 8, 9, 11, and 12, which explained 32–43% of the phenotypic variation of the trait (Additional file 1: Fig. S5 and Additional file 2: Table S5). Among them, several significant associations overlapped or were closely linked to known genes or previously detected QTLs. qAwn4 and qAwn8.2 overlapped with the two major genes, An-1 and RAE2, respectively (Bessho-Uehara et al. 2016; Luo et al. 2013). qAwn2.2 is located close to qAWNL2 and An-4 (Amarasinghe et al. 2020; Qin et al. 2021). qAwn11.1 overlapped with an awn QTL on chromosome 11 (Bessho-Uehara et al., 2021). These co-locations of the known genes/QTLs detected in previous studies could provide proof of the accuracy of our analysis. Notably, this study mapped the significant associations at position 20.6 Mbp on chromosome 9 overlapped with qAwn9. This result suggests further investigation for the fine mapping of qAwn9.
Fine Mapping of qAwn9
For the fine mapping of qAwn9, 50 BC1F2 plants with the Milyang23 allele at LABA1 and recombination events between RM201 and RM24751 on chromosome 9 were selected. Fifty BC1F2 recombinant plants were examined using additional markers to better determine crossover breakpoints. The plants in each recombinant group were then selfed to produce BC1F3 lines that were used for phenotype measurements (Fig. 5 and Additional file 2: Table S6). Based on the combination of genotypes and phenotypes of five groups of recombinant plants (R1 to R5) and the control (G13), the qAwn9 location was mapped within an interval of 199-kb between two SSR markers, RM24663 and RM24679. Within the 199 kb region, 27 genes were annotated based on the RAP-DB database (https://rapdb.dna.affrc.go.jp). Among them, five genes were predicted as hypothetical genes or encoded proteins of unknown function, whereas the other 22 genes showed functional annotations (Additional file 2: Table S7).
DNA Sequence Variants of Candidate Genes Underlying qAwn9
To identify candidate genes for qAwn9, the genomic region of qAwn9 spanning 199-kb was directly analyzed by whole-genome sequencing of parental lines. We focused on SNPs and InDels in the promoter and exon regions that lead to non-synonymous mutations. Out of 27 genes, five hypothetical genes or encoded proteins of unknown function were omitted. The sequence variants of the remaining 22 genes were examined. Potential candidate genes were shortlisted based on sequence variants between parental lines. One gene, Os09g0520400, displayed three missense variations in exon regions; four genes, Os09g0521400, Os09g0521900, Os09g0524800, and Os09g0525400, showed sequence variants in their promoters; and remaining 17 genes showed no missense variation or variation in their promoters (Additional file 1: Fig. S6 and Additional file 2: Table S8).
Haplotype Analysis of the Candidate Genes
Haplotype analysis was conducted to examine the possible functional variation of qAwn9 since qAwn9 was detected in GWAS using the KRICE_CORE set. Based on the functional annotations and sequence variations, we considered OsbZIP76 (Os09g0520400, a transcription factor gene) as the strongest candidate gene for haplotype analysis. Of the 137 accessions in KRICE_CORE set, 127 were classified into six haplotypes of OsbZIP76 based on eight SNPs in the coding region shared by at least seven accessions (Fig. 6A and Additional file 2: Table S2). The remaining 10 accessions could not be classified owing to heterozygous and/or missing data. Haplotype 1 (Hap1) was the most common and was present in 70 (55.1%; n = 127) accessions. It was also the most frequent haplotype within temperate japonica (98.3%; n = 58), and Hwaseong belonged to the Hap1. Haplotype 2 (Hap2) included 24 (18.9%; n = 127) accessions, and the predominant haplotype within indica (60%; n = 40) and Milyang23 belonged to Hap2. Haplotypes 4, 5, and 6 were predominantly carried by the indica or aus accessions. These haplotypes were relatively minor (6.3–7.9%; n = 127). Notably, Haplotype 3 (Hap3) was rare in the KRICE_CORE set (5.5%), absent in indica, aus, and aromatic, and found in one temperate japonica accession, but it was the common haplotype within tropical japonica, present in 35.3% (n = 17) of accessions, and NIL4/9 belonged to Hap3. Compared to the awn development across the six haplotypes, Hap1 and Hap3 had significantly longer awn of 12.7 and 8.7 mm than Hap2, Hap4, Hap5, and Hap6 with the mean awn length of 1.4, 0.1, 1.6, and 1.6 mm (Fig. 6A). We found that 53 (75.7%) of the 70 rice accessions in Hap1 contained the functional LABA1 allele (based on the presence or absence of the functional 1-bp deletion at the + 69 bp site; Chr. 4:25,959,586), which partly explains the long awn of the accessions in Hap1. In contrast, in Hap3, only one temperate japonica accession had a functional allele of LABA1, whereas the other six tropical japonica accessions had the nonfunctional laba1 allele, suggesting that the awn development of tropical japonica accessions might not be controlled by LABA1. All seven accessions of Hap3 showed awns. Therefore, we hypothesized that Hap3 carries a functional mutation that is associated with awn development. Given that the population structure (corresponding to subspecies) might lead to a false positive association between the awn length and haplotypes, a further comparison of the awn length between haplotypes within each subspecies was performed. Only tropical japonica and indica had sufficient accessions to at least two haplotypes for comparison. Consequently, Hap3 had significantly longer (t-test, p = 0.02) awns of 9.4 mm than Hap1, which had a mean awn length of 2.1 mm (Fig. 6B). However, no significant difference in awn length was observed between Hap2 and Hap4 in indica (Fig. 6C). This provided further evidence that Hap3 might have functional variation in awn development.
Additionally, we examined the sequence information of 36 O. rufipogon accessions from the TASUKE database based on the eight non-synonymous SNPs in OsbZIP76. Surprisingly, none of the O. rufipogons belonged to Hap3, although they were mainly classified as Hap4 (Fig. 6A and Additional file 2: Table S4). Therefore, we conclude that the Hap3 allele might be tropical japonica-specific, different from O. rufipogon, and has three non-synonymous SNPs in OsbZIP76.
To further investigate the extent of sequence variation of OsbZIP76 across O. sativa subpopulations, we built a network of haplotypes using the tool ‘haplotype network analysis’ implemented in RiceVarMap (ricevarmap.ncpgr.cn). A consistent frequency result for the six haplotypes was obtained (Additional file 1: Fig. S7A). Hap1 and Hap2 were still the most common haplotypes in the dataset and were the predominant haplotypes in japonica and indica, respectively, whereas Hap3 was the predominant haplotype in tropical japonica. For further detail, we examined the SNP-Seek database containing re-sequencing information for a collection of 3 K O. sativa accessions (http://snp-seek.irri.org). Notably, Hap3 differs from the other five haplotypes in three missense SNPs (Chr. 9:20,326,718, 20,326,993, and 20,327,598) that we previously detected in NIL4/9, Milyang23, and Hwaseong. Interestingly, among the SNPs detected in the 3 K population, these three missense mutations were predominantly observed in tropical japonica, whereas they were rare in other subspecies (Additional file 1: Fig. S7B). Based on these observations, we speculated that Hap3 is a tropical japonica-specific haplotype, and Hap3 could cause phenotypic variations.
The genetic diversity of parental lines is essential to enhance the success rate of detecting QTL/genes for complex traits. In this study, a population was developed from a cross between an indica cultivar Milyang23 with no awn and NIL4/9 with long awns that allowed us to (1) understand the effect of qAwn9 in different genetic backgrounds, (2) simultaneously detect and analyze the other QTLs for awn length and their genetic interactions in the same cross population, and (3) analyze QTLs with higher precision and resolution because of the reduced effect of unknown QTLs on awn length.
QTL mapping is further complicated by the requirement to resolve the effect of one genetic locus from the noise created by segregation at other genetic loci that also influence the trait of interest. To minimize the influence of putative QTLs on each other, two subgroups were selected based on the genotypes and phenotypes of 900 BC1F2 plants at the two putative QTLs, qAwn4 and qAwn9. For qAwn4 analysis, a single plant heterozygous for qAwn4 and Milyang23 homozygous for qAwn9 was selected. Moreover, a single plant heterozygous for qAwn9 and Milyang23 homozygous for qAwn4 was selected to analyze qAwn9. This strategy allowed us to analyze QTLs for awn length as a single Mendelian factor, which increased the statistical power and accuracy of the QTL linkage relationship. Consequently, two QTLs for awn were repeatedly detected in two consecutive generations, BC1F2 and BC1F3, indicating the accuracy of QTL mapping. Moreover, LABA1 was determined to be the causal gene for qAwn4. The Hwaseong allele contributed to awn development at this locus which is consistent with the fact that many temperate japonica accessions have an awned phenotype and harbor the functional allele of LABA1 (Hua et al. 2015). QTL analysis also detected a major QTL for awn length on chromosome 9, where the wild rice O. minuta allele increased awn length. However, the two QTLs identified in this study are only the minimum estimates of the actual number of loci influencing awn development. The parental lines used in our study may differ from other minor loci that affect awn development. For instance, some plants with Milyang23 homozygous alleles at both loci, which were expected to have no awn, showed a short-awned phenotype. This phenomenon suggested the presence of other loci with minor effects.
Interaction between LABA1 and qAwn9
In addition to understanding the function of a single gene or QTL, the characterization of the genetic interactions among them is also important. In this study, an interaction between LABA1 and qAwn9, which is involved in awn development, was detected in the BC1F2 and BC1F3 populations (p = 0.028, Table 1). However, the confidence in their detection of interactions is relatively low because of the use of the BC1F2 segregating population, which segregates parental chromosomal segments simultaneously at multiple loci. Additionally, environmental conditions are considered as factors influencing awn development. Nevertheless, the consistent results for both generations demonstrated the power of the experiment, and this population was eligible for the analysis. qAwn9 and LABA1 behaved additively during awn development and showed a stable and major effect in Milyang23 (indica) and Hwaseong (japonica) backgrounds. These results are consistent with those of previous studies. For example, three major genes for seed awning, An-1, LABA1, and RAE2, were detected to have additive effects on awn development in the genetic background of cultivated rice (Ikemoto et al. 2017; Jin et al. 2016). Similarly, a minor QTL, qAWNL2, had an additive effect with An-1 and LABA1 (Amarasinghe et al. 2020). The same type of interaction has also been demonstrated in a recent study between An-4 and other genes involved in awn development, such as An-1, LABA1, and RAE2 (Qin et al. 2021). These studies indicate that the effects of such interactions are common for awn development in rice.
Fine Mapping of qAwn9
qAwn9 represents a major and stable locus for awn development that is expressed in Hwaseong and Milyang23 backgrounds. To fine-map qAwn9 as a single Mendelian factor, we selected BC1F2 plants with Milyang23 homozygous alleles at LABA1 and recombination break points in the qAwn9 region. In addition to considering the awn length of each BC1F2 plant, segregation analysis of the awn length of the two homozygous genotypes in the BC1F3 progenies of informative F2 recombinant plants was also conducted. Segregation analysis of the BC1F3 progenies was valuable for delimiting the location of the causal QTL, considering the effect of the environment or an unknown gene on the awn phenotype in the population. Theoretically, approximately half of the progeny of BC1F2 recombinant plants are heterozygous at a given locus, which may impede the precise evaluation of their phenotypes in mapping. Combining the awn length and genotypes of two homozygous BC1F3 progeny from each recombinant plant allowed us to infer whether the target locus was segregated. Based on segregation analysis and substitution mapping, qAwn9 was mapped to a 199-kb physical region between markers RM24663 and RM24679.
Candidate Gene for Awn Development
Based on the list of genes annotated in the qAwn9 region, five hypothetical genes or encoded proteins of unknown function were omitted. We compared the sequences of 22 remaining genes between parental lines and found four genes, Os09g0521400, Os09g0521900, Os09g0524800, and Os09g0525400, had SNP or deletion variations in the promoter region, whereas the transcription factor gene, Os09g0520400 (OsbZIP76), had three missense variations in the coding sequence. Many studies have characterized awn genes in rice and barley, most of which encode transcription factors or enzymes. As mentioned above, LABA1 encodes a cytokinin synthesis enzyme, whereas RAE2 is predicted to encode a small secretory signal peptide belonging to the EPIDERMAL PATTERNING FACTOR-LIKE family (Hua et al. 2015; Jin et al. 2016). Notably, three genes, An-1, TOB1, and DL, are transcription factors. An-1 encodes a bHLH transcription factor (Luo et al. 2013), whereas TOB1 and DL encode the YABBY transcription factors (Toriba and Hirano 2014; Tanaka et al. 2012). In barley, three major genes have been identified at the molecular level, all of which encode transcription factors: six-rowed spike 1 (vrs1), hooded lemma 1 (Kap1), and short awn 2 (lks2) (Huang et al. 2021). Of these, two genes, vrs1 and lks2, harbor missense mutations that are functional variations in awn development. Transcription factors are proteins that typically regulate the expression of a group of genes involved in a pathway or developmental process such as awn initiation and elongation. OsbZIP76, encoding a transcription factor, also revealed three missense mutations in variant calling between the parental lines. Therefore, it is unsurprising that candidate gene OsbZIP76 is the causal gene underlying qAwn9. Moreover, a further comparison of awn length between the haplotypes of OsbZIP76 within the tropical japonica subpopulation showed that Hap3 had significantly longer awns than Hap1. This finding provides further evidence that OsbZIP76 may be a target gene. However, additional experiments, such as gene transformation, are required to confirm the function of OsbZIP76 in awn development.
O. minuta: A Valuable Resource to Identify a New Awn Gene
Previous studies have used recombinant inbred lines and advanced backcross populations developed from crosses between an indica/japonica of O. sativa and a strain of O. rufipogon to detect QTLs and identify their underlying genes (Shim et al. 2020; Ngu et al. 2014). Three major genes, An-2, RAE2, and An-1, have been cloned using chromosome segment substitution lines derived from interspecific cross between O. sativa and O. rufipogon (Luo et al. 2013; Gu et al. 2015; Ikemoto et al. 2017). Some minor QTLs, qAWNL2 and An-4, have also been detected using populations derived from interspecific crosses (Amarasinghe et al. 2020; Qin et al. 2021). Recently, a study explored the loci responsible for awn development in rice through a comparative analysis of all AA genome species (Bessho-Uehara et al. 2021). Most known genes/QTLs for awn development were also detected, and two loci on chromosomes 7 and 11 were newly identified in that study. However, qAwn9 was not identified in previous studies. The wild rice O. minuta (2n = 48, BBCC) is an allotetraploid genome species in the Oryza officinalis complex and has the second largest genome size among Oryza species, at 1124 Mbp (Elgamal and Elshenawy 2018). It has accumulated abundant genetic diversity and harbors a long awn. Thus, it can be used as a donor for developing mapping population and will probably lead to the discovery of novel genes involved in awn development in rice. The cross combinations between Milyang23/Hwaseong and O. minuta could explain why qAwn9 was detected in our studies but was not mapped in the above studies. Indeed, extensive genetic research based on haplotype analysis in this study indicated that Hap3 of OsbZIP76 in the qAwn9 region is rare in aus, indica, temperate japonica, and O. rufipogon strains and was exclusively observed in tropical japonica and O. minuta. Therefore, the special long-awned line NIL4/9 is very valuable and provides a material base for the present study. However, we cannot currently provide evidence on how the unique alleles of Hap3 were produced, although it is possible that natural mutations in the qAwn9 genomic region within tropical japonica adapted to the environmental conditions in a unique domestication history or the accessions containing clustered sequences, including Hap3, may still retain the original alleles of their wild progenitors. A similar result was found when other genes surrounding OsbZIP76 were screened. Two genes, Os09g0520100 and Os09g0521300, also contained unique alleles in tropical japonica, indicating the presence of a tropical japonica-specific clustered sequence in this region (Additional file 1: Fig. S8). In addition, the unique alleles of Os09g0520100 at position 20,315,260 were the same as those detected in O. minuta. It is unclear whether there is any close relationship between tropical japonica and O. minuta because of the same exclusive alleles detected in this study and the same local origin in Indonesia, the Philippines, and the southern part of Indochina as reported in a previous study (Konishi et al. 2008; Elgamal and Elshenawy 2018) or it possibly occurred by crossing between tropical japonica and O. minuta. Much remains to be learned to provide further insight into rice domestication.
In the present study, QTL analysis revealed that two loci, LABA1 and qAwn9, were mainly responsible for awn development in NIL4/9. The combination of LABA1 and qAwn9 showed an additive effect, and both loci could independently induce awn. Therefore, to control awnlessness via breeding programs, the accumulation of natural variations at all awning loci should be considered. The qAwn9 was fine-mapped in our study using an interspecific cross between O. minuta and cultivated rice, supporting the importance of wild rice as a resource that is valuable for rice breeding and provides a potential opportunity for identifying novel genes. qAwn9 is an important molecular target for understanding the genetic control of awn development in rice. This study provides novel insights into the genetic architecture of awn development and establishes the basis for candidate gene analysis to lay a foundation for further cloning of the awn gene underlying qAwn9.
Availability of Data and Materials
All data supporting the conclusions described here are provided in tables and figures.
Basic leucine zipper
Cetyl trimethy ammonium bromide
Genome-wide association study
Mixed linear model
Polymerase chain reactions
Quantitative trait loci
Single nucleotide polymorphisms
Simple sequence repeats
Amarasinghe YPJ, Kuwata R, Nishimura A, Phan PDT, Ishikawa R, Ishii T (2020) Evaluation of domestication loci associated with awnlessness in cultivated rice, Oryza sativa. Rice 13:26
Awika JM (2011) Major cereal grains production and use around the world. In: Advances in cereal science: implications to food processing and health promotion. American Chemical Society, Washington
Bessho-Uehara K, Wang DR, Furuta T, Minami A, Nagai K, Gamuyao R, Asano K, Angeles-Shim RB, Shimizu Y, Ayano M (2016) Loss of function at RAE2, a previously unidentified EPFL, is required for awnlessness in cultivated Asian rice. Proc Natl Acad Sci 113:8969–8974
Bessho-Uehara K, Yamagata Y, Takashi T, Makino T, Yasui H, Yoshimura A, Ashikari M (2021) Exploring the loci responsible for awn development in rice through comparative analysis of All AA genome species. Plants 10:725
Doebley JF, Gaut BS, Smith BD (2006) The molecular genetics of crop domestication. Cell 127:1309–1321
Elbaum R, Zaltzman L, Burgert I, Fratzl P (2007) The role of wheat awns in the seed dispersal unit. Science 316:884–886
Elgamal WH, Elshenawy MM (2018) Oryza minuta J. Presl. ex CB Persl. The wild Oryza genomes. Springer, Cham
Gu B, Zhou T, Luo J, Liu H, Wang Y, Shangguan Y, Zhu J, Li Y, Sang T, Wang Z (2015) An-2 encodes a cytokinin synthesis enzyme that regulates awn length and grain production in rice. Mol Plant 8:1635–1650
Hua L, Wang DR, Tan L, Fu Y, Liu F, Xiao L, Zhu Z, Fu Q, Sun X, Gu P (2015) LABA1, a domestication gene associated with long, barbed awns in wild rice. Plant Cell 27:1875–1888
Huang B, Wu W, Hong Z (2021) Genetic loci underlying awn morphology in barley. Genes 12:1613
Ishii T, Ishikawa R (2018) Domestication loci controlling panicle shape, seed shattering, and seed awning. In: Rice genomics, genetics and breeding. Springer, Singapore
Ikemoto M, Otsuka M, Thanh PT, Phan PDT, Ishikawa R, Ishii T (2017) Gene interaction at seed-awning loci in the genetic background of wild rice. Genes Genet Syst 92:21–26
Jin J, Hua L, Zhu Z, Tan L, Zhao X, Zhang W, Liu F, Fu Y, Cai H, Sun X (2016) GAD1 encodes a secreted peptide that regulates grain number, grain length, and awn development in rice domestication. Plant Cell 28:2453–2463
Kim T-S, He Q, Kim K-W, Yoon M-Y, Ra W-H, Li FP, Tong W, Yu J, Oo WH, Choi B, Heo E-B, Yun B-K, Kwon S-J, Kwon S-W, Cho Y-H, Lee C-Y, Park B-S, Park Y-J (2016) Genome-wide resequencing of KRICE_CORE reveals their potential for future breeding, as well as functional and evolutionary studies in the post-genomic era. BMC Genomics 17:408
Konishi S, Ebana K, Izawa T (2008) Inference of the japonica rice domestication process from the distribution of six functional nucleotide polymorphisms of domestication-related genes in various landraces and modern cultivars. Plant Cell Physiol 49:1283–1293
Linh L-H, Jin F-X, Kang K-H, Lee Y-T, Kwon S-J, Ahn S-N (2006) Mapping quantitative trait loci for heading date and awn length using an advanced backcross line from a cross between Oryza sativa and O. minuta. Breed Sci 56:341–349
Luo J, Liu H, Zhou T, Gu B, Huang X, Shangguan Y, Zhu J, Li Y, Zhao Y, Wang Y, Zhao Q, Wang A, Wang Z, Sang T, Wang Z, Han B (2013) An-1 encodes a basic helix-loop-helix protein that regulates awn development, grain size, and grain number in rice. Plant Cell 25:3360–3376
Murray MG, Thompson WF (1980) Rapid isolation of high molecular weight plant DNA. Nucleic Acids Res 8:4321–4325
Ngu MS, Thomson MJ, Bhuiyan MA, Ho C, Wickneswari R (2014) Fine mapping of a grain weight quantitative trait locus, qGW6, using near isogenic lines derived from Oryza rufipogon IRGC105491 and Oryza sativa cultivar MR219. Genet Mol Res 13:9477–9488
Qin B, Lu T, Xu Y, Shen W, Liu F, Xie X, Li Y, Wang K, Li R (2021) Identification and characterization of An-4, a potential quantitative trait locus for awn development in rice. BMC Plant Biol 21:298
Ross-Ibarra J, Morrell Peter L, Gaut Brandon S (2007) Plant domestication, a unique opportunity to identify the genetic basis of adaptation. Proc Natl Acad Sci 104:8641–8648
Shim KC, Kim SH, Lee HS, Adeva C, Jeon YA, Luong NH, Kim WJ, Akhtamov M, Park YJ, Ahn SN (2020) Characterization of a new qLTG3-1 allele for low-temperature germinability in rice from the wild species Oryza rufipogon. Rice 13:10
Solis CA, Yong MT, Vinarao R, Jena K, Holford P, Shabala L, Zhou M, Shabala S, Chen Z-H (2020) Back to the wild: on a quest for donors toward salinity tolerant rice. Front Plant Sci 11:323–323
Sweeney M, McCouch S (2007) The complex history of the domestication of rice. Ann Bot 100:951–957
Tanaka W, Toriba T, Ohmori Y, Yoshida A, Kawai A, Mayama-Tsuchida T, Ichikawa H, Mitsuda N, Ohme-Takagi M, Hirano H-Y (2012) The YABBY gene TONGARI-BOUSHI1 is involved in lateral organ development and maintenance of meristem organization in the rice spikelet. Plant Cell 24:80–95
Tang H, Sezen U, Paterson AH (2010) Domestication and plant genomes. Curr Opin Plant Biol 13:160–166
Toriba T, Hirano HY (2014) The DROOPING LEAF and OsETTIN 2 genes promote awn development in rice. Plant J 77:616–626
Wang L, Wang A, Huang X, Zhao Q, Dong G, Qian Q, Sang T, Han B (2011) Mapping 49 quantitative trait loci at high resolution through sequencing-based genotyping of rice recombinant inbred lines. Theor Appl Genet 122:327–340
Yoshioka M, Iehisa JCM, Ohno R, Kimura T, Enoki H, Nishimura S, Nasuda S, Takumi S (2017) Three dominant awnless genes in common wheat: Fine mapping, interaction and contribution to diversity in awn shape and length. PLoS ONE 12:e0176148
Zhang Y, Zhang Z, Sun X, Zhu X, Li B, Li J, Guo H, Chen C, Pan Y, Liang Y, Xu Z, Zhang H, Li Z (2019) Natural alleles of GLA for grain length and awn development were differently domesticated in rice subspecies japonica and indica. Plant Biotechnol J 17:1547–1559
We would like to thank Mrs. Yong-Sook Kim, Mr. Kyo-Hwui Lee, Ms. Ho-Sun Kim for their excellent technical support.
This work was carried out with the support of "Cooperative Research Program for Agriculture Science and Technology Development (Project No. PJ015757)" Rural Development Administration, Republic of Korea.
Ethics Approval and Consent to Participate
Consent for Publication
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Additional file 1
: Fig S1 Confirmation of the O. minuta segment in the NIL4/9 background. The O. minuta and Milyang23 alleles were segregated at the RM24663 (A) and VRN10 (B) loci in the subset of F2 plants with no Hwaseong allele. S, Size marker; H, Hwaseong homozygous; M, Milyang23 homozygous; MN, heterozygous; N, O. minuta homozygous. Fig S2 Genotype analysis of two extreme phenotype groups to detect markers linked to the additional QTL for seed awning. Polymorphisms of three representative markers, RM252 (A), ID-J2 (B), and RM525 (C), are shown. MM, Milyang23 homozygous; MN, Heterozygous; NN, NIL4/9 homozygous. Fig S3 Comparison of the awn length in the BC1F2 and BC1F3 populations that are segregating only at qAwn9 (A) and LABA1 (B), respectively. MM, Milyang23 homozygous; MN, heterozygous; NN, O. minuta homozygous on (A) or Hwaseong homozygous on (B). Means labeled with different letters above each box are significantly different among genotypes (Tukey’s test, p < 0.05). n1): number of plants. Fig S4 Sequence comparison of the LABA1 exon region between parental lines. The black and white boxes indicate exons and UTR regions, respectively. One C-nucleotide deletion (+69 position) was found in the first exon of LABA1 in Milyang23 compared with NIL4/9 and Hwaseong and resulted in a truncated protein with only 55 amino acids compared to 250 amino acids in the wild types. Fig S5 Manhattan plots of p-values analyzed using a mixed linear model (MLM) for awn development. The red line indicates the threshold. Fig S6 Gene structure of the OsbZIP76 and SNPs among NIL4/9, Milyang23, and Hwaseong. Black boxes and lines indicate exons and introns, respectively. Red lines indicate nucleotide variation.Fig S7 Haplotype and allele frequency in OsbZIP76 in the database for big natural populations. (A) Haplotype network of OsbZIP76 constructed using the tool ‘haplotype network analysis’ (http://ricevarmap.ncpgr.cn). Each circle represents a haplotype, and the size is proportionate to the number of accessions in the corresponding haplotype. Branch length represents the genetic distance between two haplotypes. (B) Allele frequency chart of each SNP position in the OsbZIP76 region for all or each subspecies of the 3 K rice accessions (http://snp-seek.irri.org). Ind1, ind2, and ind3 are three groups of indica rice; indx corresponds to other indica varieties, temp is temperate japonica, trop is tropical japonica, japx is other japonica varieties, aus is aus, indx is admixed aus and indica, aro is aromatic and admix is all other unassigned varieties. Red arrows indicate the positions of three missense mutations that we previously detected between NIL4/9, Milyang23, and Hwaseong. Fig S8 Confirmation of a tropical japonica-specific clustered sequence in the surrounding location of OsbZIP76. Allele frequency chart of each SNP position in Os09g0520100 (A) and Os09g0521300 (B) genes for all or tropical japonica of the 3 K rice accessions (http://snp-seek.irri.org). Red circles indicate the positions of tropical japonica-specific alleles.
Additional file 2
: Table S1 List of molecular markers used for QTL analysis and fine mapping.Table S2 Passport information of 137 rice accessions (KRICE_CORE set). Table S3 Summary of the whole-genome sequencing result for the parental lines. Table S4 List of TASUKE 36 O. rufipogon accessions (https://rapdb.dna.affrc.go.jp). Table S5 Summary information of significant associations detected by GWAS. Table S6 Average awn lengths (mm) and standard deviations observed for homozygous genotypes derived from critical recombinant plants. Table S7 List of annotated genes in the 199-kb target region of qAwn9.Table S8 Summary of variant identification and annotation of candidate genes.
Rights and permissions
Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article's Creative Commons licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article's Creative Commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this licence, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/.
About this article
Cite this article
Luong, N.H., Balkunde, S.G., Shim, KC. et al. Characterization of Domestication Loci Associated with Awn Development in Rice. Rice 15, 61 (2022). https://doi.org/10.1186/s12284-022-00607-y
- Quantitative trait loci
- Awn development
- O. minuta